Shareholder, joint venture and commercial disputes
Nathan acts for companies, directors and shareholders in disputes concerning corporate control, directors’ duties, contractual rights and joint venture investments. He represents clients in litigation and arbitration, with experience ranging from derivative actions and unfair prejudice petitions to disputes involving private equity investments.
Investment and fund disputes
Nathan acts for investors and funds in claims involving the mis-selling of financial products, negligent portfolio management and alleged misappropriation of assets. He also advises on disputes within investment funds, including carried interest entitlements, the termination of senior personnel and separation arrangements.
SFC investigations and contentious regulatory matters
Nathan represents clients in Securities and Futures Commission (SFC) investigations and related proceedings before the Market Misconduct Tribunal, the Securities and Futures Appeals Tribunal and the Hong Kong courts. His experience includes alleged insider dealing, challenges to investigative powers and access to evidence in disciplinary proceedings.
He also advises regulators, including The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong, the Accounting and Financial Reporting Council and the Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants, on their statutory and public law functions. His work encompasses judicial review and professional disciplinary proceedings, and he has been engaged as an expert witness on Hong Kong securities laws and regulations.
Related experience
His wider practice includes fraud, asset tracing and recovery, insolvency-related litigation, professional negligence and audit claims. He has more than 20 years’ litigation experience in Hong Kong and is admitted in Hong Kong and New Zealand.
Career Highlights
Selected Matters
Shareholder and joint venture disputes
- East Asia Satellite Television (Holdings) Ltd v New Cotai LLC and others HCA 2189/2009 – Representing a shareholder in a joint venture dispute with two large US hedge funds over the development of a casino in Macau, including commencing a derivative action and petition for unfair prejudice in the Court of First Instance (CFI), in a claim for damages of US$2b.
- Passport Special Opportunities Master Fund, LP and Anor v Esun Holdings Limited and Others [2011] 4 HKC 62 – Acting for a listed company and its directors in a derivative action brought by a large US hedge fund against the defendants for breach of fiduciary duties to the Hong Kong listed company, in connection with a placement of shares by the company which was allegedly for the improper purpose of preventing a takeover by the fund.
- Trinityville Profit Ltd v Internet Fund II Pte Ltd HCMP 858/2015 – Acting for Ganji.com in a dispute with a number of private equity funds with equity interests in Ganji.com. Ganji was valued in excess of US$1b.
Investment and investment fund disputes
- Zhang Hong Li v DBS Bank (Hong Kong) Ltd [2019] HKCFA 18 – Acting for a trust in proceedings before the CFI, Court of Appeal (CA) and Court of Final Appeal (CFA) in a claim for damages in excess of US$60m relating to negligent mis-selling of financial derivatives by DBS Bank.
- Real Estate and Finance Fund (In Liquidation) v Sun Cheuk Pak Alan and Others [2025] HKCFI 2478 – Acting for two investment funds in proceedings before the CFI and CA in a claim for damages in excess of US$75m relating to fraudulent misappropriation of fund assets by the former managers of the fund.
- Joe Zhixiong Zhou v SAIF Partners II LP [2020] HKCFA 9 – Acting for a former partner of a prominent private equity fund in proceedings before the CFI, CA and CFA in a dispute over contractual entitlement to carried interest and allegations of diversion of business opportunities, in a claim for damages in excess of US$20m.
Securities investigations and enforcement proceedings
- Y v SFC HCMP 2848/2016 – Acting for a prominent Mainland company in challenging the lawfulness of searches and seizures of the company’s premises, which were conducted by staff of the SFC for the purposes of investigations under section 183 of the Securities and Futures Ordinance.
- SFC v Tiger Asia Management [2012] 2 HKLRD 281 – Acting for the founder of Tiger Asia Management in proceedings brought by the SFC under s. 213 of the Securities and Futures Ordinance against a hedge fund and its officers in relation to alleged insider dealing.
- SFC v Lee Sung Ho HCA 2177/2011 – Acting for a Korean corporation in proceedings brought by the SFC under s. 213 of the Securities and Futures Ordinance against the corporation in relation to alleged insider dealing, in which the leave granted to serve the proceedings on the corporation outside the jurisdiction was set aside.
- X v SFC [2012] 4 HKLRD 296 – Acting for a prominent financial institution in judicial review proceedings against the SFC, which determined the extent to which subjects of disciplinary proceedings under Part IX of the Securities and Futures Ordinance are entitled to access to evidence in the possession of the SFC.
- Report of the Market Misconduct Tribunal in respect of dealings in the shares of China Overseas Land and Investment (8 July 2009) – Acting for a specified person in the first ever Market Misconduct Tribunal proceedings for insider dealing in Hong Kong.
- Luk Ka Cheung v The Market Misconduct Tribunal HCAL 49/2008 – Acting for a specified person in challenging the constitutionality of the Market Misconduct Tribunal, on the grounds that the Tribunal contravened the separation of powers requirements of the Basic Law.
Accounting and audit negligence
- Victory City International Holdings Limited (In Liquidation) v Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu [2025] HKCFI 5505 – Acting for a former listed company against Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu in proceedings before the CFI, in a claim for damages of approximately US$1b for alleged negligence in the audit of the Group’s consolidated accounts.
- JH CPA Alliance Ltd v The Accounting and Financial Reporting Council AFFRT/1/2025 – Acting for the Accounting and Financial Reporting Council in proceedings before the Accounting and Financial Reporting Review Tribunal in review proceedings brought by an accounting firm and two of its representatives, concerning disciplinary proceedings for alleged failures in auditing a listed company.
- The Registrar of the Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants v KPMG D–16–1206F – Acting for the Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants in disciplinary proceedings against KPMG and two of its partners for audit failures in connection with China Forestry Holdings Co Ltd, a listed company which collapsed after the discovery of widespread fraud.
- Wong Tak Man Stephen v Registrar of the Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants [2018] 4 HKC 173 – Acting for the Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants in proceedings before the Court of Final Appeal challenging the application of certain professional standards to the accounting profession, in a case which confirmed strict liability for compliance with auditing standards.
Competition law
- Competition Commission v Quadient Technologie & others CTEA 1/2021 – Acted for the Hong Kong Competition Commission in an enforcement action before the Competition Tribunal in relation to the respondents’ agreement to fix prices, rig bids and allocate customers.
- Competition Commission v Quantr Ltd CTEA 1/2020 – Acting for the Competition Commission in an enforcement action before the Competition Tribunal against an IT company and its director, for price fixing in the course of bidding for contracts.
Public law cases
- Target Insurance Holdings Limited v The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited (HCAL 1343/2025) – Acting for the Stock Exchange in judicial review proceedings before the CFI and CA, challenging the process adopted by the Listing Review Committee of the Exchange in disciplinary proceedings, in a case which confirmed the permissibility of administrative assistance when drafting decisions.
- Cai Zhengrong v The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Ltd [2021] HKCA 1179 – Acting for the Stock Exchange in judicial review proceedings before the CFI and CA, challenging the application of Rule 6.01A of the Listing Rules and the Exchange’s delisting process, in a case which confirmed the underlying lawfulness of the process.
- HLB Hodgson Impey Cheng (a firm) v The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants – Acting for the Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants in judicial review proceedings before the CFI, CA and CFA, challenging the lawfulness of the delegation of investigation functions by a statutory Investigation Committee, in a case which determined the application of constitutional independence requirements to such bodies.
- Mandy Tam Heung Man v The Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants [2008] 1 HKLRD 238 – Acted for the Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants in judicial review proceedings before the CFI, brought by the Legco representative for the accounting functional constituency asserting an entitlement to distribute political materials to the Institute’s members, in a case which defined the relationship between Legco members and the professional body of their functional constituency.
- Peter Po Fun Chan v Winnie CW Cheung (2007) 10 HKCFAR 676 – Acting for the Registrar of the Hong Kong Institute of Certified Public Accountants in judicial review proceedings before the CFI, CA and CFA, challenging the lawfulness of a decision in relation to restoration to the register of certified public accountants, in a case which revised the threshold for obtaining leave to apply for judicial review.
- The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited v New World Development Co Ltd (2006) 9 HKCFAR 234 – Acting for the Stock Exchange in judicial review proceedings before the CFI, CA and CFA, challenging the lawfulness of the Exchange’s disciplinary procedures and the prohibition on lawyers making oral submissions to the Disciplinary Committee, in a case which considered whether parties in such proceedings were entitled to the constitutional protections applicable to court proceedings.
Telecommunications litigation
- Cinepoly Records Company Limited and others v Hong Kong Broadband Network Limited and others HCMP 943/2006 – Acting for an internet service provider in proceedings by the music industry against internet service providers seeking disclosure of personal data of customers who had conducted illegal “peer to peer” music downloading through a computer network on the internet.
- PCCW-HKT Telephone Limited and PCCW-IMS Limited v The Telecommunications Authority HCCL 115/2004 – Acting for PCCW in its judicial review in respect of the Telecommunications Authority’s decision to allow HKBN to operate VOIP services on the broadband network.
- PCCW-HKT Telephone Limited v The Telecommunications Authority HCAL 63/2004 – Acting for PCCW (FTNS licensee) in successfully quashing by way of judicial review the Telecommunications Authority’s Statement regarding the review of the principles and costing methodology of the Local Access Charges, a determination regarding the level of LAC to be levied by the applicant.
- PCCW-HKT Telephone Limited v The Telecommunications Authority HCAL 152/2002 – Acting for PCCW (FTNS licensee) in successfully quashing by way of judicial review the Telecommunications Authority’s direction requiring the applicants to implement Broadband Type II Interconnection prior to determination of commercial terms.